Major Leagues

Is Juan Soto’s contract the most toxic in MLB, or do the numbers tell a different story?

Although Juan Soto’s record-breaking $765 million contract is often a target for criticism in New York, his elite offensive production in 2026 refutes any label of failure.

Juan Soto and his exorbitant contract remain right in the eye of the media storm. Photo: New York Mets / MLB Filmroom
Juan Soto and his exorbitant contract remain right in the eye of the media storm. Photo: New York Mets / MLB Filmroom

Although Juan Soto’s record-breaking $765 million contract is often a target for criticism in New York, his elite offensive production in 2026 refutes any label of failure.

An analysis based on Spotrac salary data and 2026 statistics shows that Juan Soto continues to justify his contract with the Mets, posting an OPS of .908. 

The debate over the most toxic contract in Major League Baseball often immediately points toward Queens (Juan Soto). When a player signs a record-breaking 15-year, $765 million deal with the New York Mets, featuring an average annual value (AAV) of $51 million and a commitment running through the 2039 season, every year that passes without a World Series title fuels the criticism.

However, when comparing the salary figures recorded on Spotrac, research conducted by that portal and verified by the statistics department at our outlet, Swing Completo, against actual on-field performance during the 2026 season, it becomes clear that singling out Juan Soto is driven more by collective frustration than by financial reality.

Despite two stints on the injured list due to calf issues, which limited him to 111 games, Juan Soto maintained an elite offensive pace. In 400 at-bats, he posted a slash line of .275/.393/.515, with 27 home runs, 68 RBIs, an OPS of .908, and an OPS+ of 154 (meaning he was 54% better than the league average), contributing 3.0 WAR, according to data from Baseball-Reference.

In New York, they are paying a historic sum, with 13 seasons and $663 million still on the books, prior to an opt-out clause after 2029, but in exchange, they get a generational hitter who continues to be a difference-maker whenever he is healthy. The real contractual problem in baseball lies with other franchises that have mortgaged their financial flexibility for players who are clearly in decline.

Three deals that currently act as financial anchors

When analyzing the cost-to-performance ratio looking ahead to 2027, three contracts stand out for their poor on-field return:

  • Javier Báez (Detroit Tigers): Represents the most critical case in the league. In December 2021 he signed for six years and 140 million guaranteed (23.33 million AAV). In 2026 he only played 58 games in which he hit .241/.270/.364 with three home runs, 20 RBIs, a poor OPS of .634 (OPS+ of 76), and a negative WAR of -0.5. Detroit will still have to pay him a full 24 million in 2027 for a player who diminishes value on the field.
  • Xander Bogaerts (San Diego Padres): The 11-season, $280 million contract ($25.45 million AAV) signed in 2022 is starting to look like an uphill battle. In 2026, over the course of 153 games, Bogaerts managed a slash line of just .231/.332/.344, with 13 home runs, 57 RBIs, a .676 OPS (90 OPS+), and 2.2 WAR. Most alarming for San Diego is that they still owe him $175 million between 2027 and 2033 ($25 million per season) while his power at the plate continues to fade.
  • Willy Adames (San Francisco Giants): After signing a seven-year, $182 million contract ($26 million AAV) heading into 2025, his second year in the Bay Area raised some red flags. Although he hit 21 home runs in 121 games before suffering a ligament sprain in his left elbow in August, his batting average dropped to .230, and he posted the lowest on-base percentage of his career at .289 (.424 slugging percentage, .713 OPS, and 1.7 WAR). Furthermore, he has $140 million in guaranteed money remaining over the next five years, with his base salary set to jump from $10 million in 2026 to $28 million annually between 2027 and 2031.

The True Meaning of a "Toxic" Contract Heading Toward 2027

In Major League Baseball front offices, a "toxic" contract isn't defined by the sheer size of the paycheck but rather by the gap between what is paid and what is received in return. While Juan Soto remains a hitter with an OPS above .900, capable of anchoring an entire offense, teams like Detroit, San Diego, and San Francisco are saddled with multi-million dollar commitments (many protected by no-trade clauses) for players who are currently performing below the league’s offensive average. Looking ahead to 2027, the real financial burden lies with those who are paid like stars but fail to produce like them.

Who is Juan Soto?

Juan Soto (born in Santo Domingo, 1998) is a Dominican Major League Baseball outfielder who debuted in 2018 with the Washington Nationals, the franchise with which he won the 2019 World Series and a batting title in 2020. After also shining for the San Diego Padres and the New York Yankees, he cemented his status as one of modern baseball’s premier superstars by signing a record-breaking 15-year, $765 million contract with the New York Mets.

For more news on Latin American baseball, follow our WhatsApp channel.

CEO & Founder of Swing Completo | Sports Journalist & MLB Specialist A distinguished sports journalist and media executive with over 20 years of experience, I serve as the CEO and Founder of Swing Completo LLC, based in Connecticut, U.S. My work centers on driving editorial strategy and scaling digital infrastructure to provide high-authority coverage of Major League Baseball (MLB) for the Hispanic community. Since 2015, I have been a key member of the ESPN production team in Bristol, CT. During this tenure, I have been honored with multiple Sports Emmy Awards for excellence in MLB coverage—encompassing World Series, Little League World Series, and Spring Training—as well as contributions to the award-winning production team for SportsCenter. Throughout my career, I have collaborated with prominent Spanish-language sports media in the U.S., including ESPN Deportes. Additionally, I served as Press Chief for the Cuban Professional Baseball Federation (FEPCUBE), leading communications for international baseball initiatives. I hold a degree in Social Communication complemented by a Master’s degree in Sports Journalism. Under my leadership, Swing Completo has become a premier reference for U.S.-based Hispanic audiences. Our growth, marked by the YouTube Silver Creator Award and recognition by Google in case studies regarding media growth and SEO optimization, reflects my commitment to merging rigorous, traditional journalism with modern digital innovation. My current focus remains on producing expert-led content and advancing the technological standards of sports news platforms.
See more

More News

Jurickson Profar received the largest penalty in Major League Baseball in 2026.
Major Leagues

Jurickson Profar loses $15 million after 162-game suspension in 2026

Jurickson Profar's second PED suspension has cost him an entire MLB season and $15 million, raising serious questions about his future with the Atlanta Braves.

Guillermo Sanchez -
Tarik Skubal displays spectacular command from the mound in the Major Leagues.
Major Leagues

Why is Tarik Skubal untouchable in Major League Baseball?

Tarik Skubal dominates Major League offenses thanks to surgical command, vertical deception, and a lethal changeup.

Daniel De Malas -
Yordan Alvarez joins six MLB legends in a historic seven-player club.
Major Leagues

Yordan Alvarez makes MLB history: Only 7 players have achieved this rare combination

Yordan Alvarez joins six MLB legends in an exclusive club.

Daniel De Malas -
Maikel García didn’t stay silent; even though he didn’t understand Ohtani’s language, he responded in true Venezuelan fashion.
Major Leagues

Maikel García reveals previously undisclosed encounter with Ohtani during the 2026 World Baseball Classic

The Venezuelan major leaguers described the adrenaline and the provocations during the matchup against Japan moments that the television cameras failed to capture.

Daniel De Malas -
Tarik Skubal is the most valuable player in the 2027 MLB free-agent market.
Major Leagues

MLB Free Agency: 5 Potential Landing Spots for Tarik Skubal and a $350 Million Contract

Tarik Skubal headlines the 2026-27 MLB free-agent market. The Dodgers, Mets, Cubs and Yankees are among the teams in contention to land the star left-hander.

Daniel De Malas -
Rafael Devers finished with a .258 batting average.
Major Leagues

Rafael Devers: The adjustment to his swing, now threatened by the MLB work stoppage

Adjusting his reaction time to high-velocity pitches is vital for solidifying his offensive profile before the impending MLB lockout disrupts the 2027 competitive schedule.

Daniel De Malas -
Luis Arráez is projected to earn around $18 million per year.
Major Leagues

Luis Arráez: 3 Teams That Could Sign Him in 2026 MLB Free Agency

Luis Arráez is heading back to the free-agent market with a stronger case than before. His offensive production and defensive improvement make him an intriguing option for three MLB teams.

Jose Alejandro Rodriguez -
2026-27 MLB Offseason Calendar.
Major Leagues

2026-27 MLB Offseason Calendar: Key Dates, Awards and Potential Moves

The 2026-27 MLB offseason calendar is taking shape, but a potential labor dispute threatens to disrupt the plans of all 30 franchises.

Daniel De Malas -
Randy Arozarena finished the 2026 MLB regular season with the Seattle Mariners batting .281/.381/.484.
Major Leagues

MLB: Randy Arozarena Projected to Land 124 Million Contract

Coming off the best season of his career, the Cuban outfielder is projected to earn a five-year deal worth $124 million, according to The Athletic's Jim Bowden.

Daniel De Malas -
Logo SWC
En
Logo SWC
En