Sandy Alcántara’s performance in 2026 has strengthened his case for a long-term contract, putting the Miami Marlins in a position to make an important decision about the Dominican right-hander’s future.

Miami fell short of its goals this season and failed to reach the postseason. With 2027 in mind, the front office must decide whether to retain one of its most valuable pitchers or allow him to enter the open market, where he continues to command considerable interest.

The Marlins addressed Sandy Alcántara’s future early in his career, signing him to a contract extension in 2021 that guaranteed him more than 50 million. That agreement included a club option for the 2027 season, giving the organization control over his immediate future.

According to contract projections from Spotrac, Alcántara’s market value stands at approximately 19.5 million per year. He could potentially secure a four-year deal worth close to $80 million if Miami declines to exercise its option.

Major Leagues MLB: Has Jazz Chisholm Jr.’s value dropped? Here is the projection for his worth in free agency

Sandy Alcántara put together a strong season in MLB

For the first time since 2022, Alcántara surpassed 200 innings pitched with the Marlins. He also recorded 153 strikeouts, his highest total since that same season, and finished with a winning record for the first time in four years.

The right-hander went 13-11 while reestablishing himself as a dependable presence in Miami’s rotation. His performance also helped explain why several teams reportedly showed interest in acquiring him before the trade deadline.

At least half of MLB’s 30 organizations could benefit from adding a pitcher of Alcántara’s caliber to the top of their rotations. Trade speculation surrounded the Dominican throughout the season, but no deal materialized, leaving him in Miami as the organization evaluates its options for 2027.

The numbers behind Alcántara’s potential salary

Alcántara’s contractual situation presents the Marlins with two primary considerations heading into the offseason:

• 2027 club option: 21 million.
• Estimated open-market value: 19.5 million per year, according to Spotrac.

Miami could exercise the 21 million option and keep Alcántara under contract for another season. If the organization declines the option, it would owe him a 2 million buyout, allowing him to pursue a contract elsewhere.

That second scenario could create an opportunity for Alcántara to secure a multiyear deal. A four-year contract approaching 80 million would place him among the notable free-agent starting pitchers in his age range.

How other starting pitchers have fared on the market

Recent contracts signed by established starting pitchers offer some context for Alcántara’s potential earning power.

Although Alcántara’s individual numbers were not overwhelming in every category, he finished the regular season strongly. In his final two appearances, he worked out of the bullpen and recorded two saves. It was the first season of his career in which he earned a save, and he finished with three overall.

Beyond his individual statistics, Alcántara has continued to establish himself in the Marlins’ record book. In 2026, he climbed to the top of the franchise’s all-time rankings in innings pitched, strikeouts and quality starts.

His durability and experience could make him an attractive option for teams seeking a proven starter, particularly if he becomes available without a long-term commitment to Miami.

Sandy Alcántara’s 2026 MLB statistics

• Games pitched: 36
• Starts: 33
• Wins: 13
• Losses: 11
• Saves: 3
• ERA: 3.87
• WHIP: 1.23
• Walks: 59
• Strikeouts: 153
• Strikeout-to-walk ratio: 2.59
• Strikeouts per nine innings: 6.43
• Winning percentage: .542

Marlins management has not ruled out keeping Alcántara

After the 2026 season ended, Miami's executives reviewed the team's performance and addressed the future of several key players. Peter Bendix, the Marlins' president of baseball operations, made it clear that Alcántara remains highly valued within the organization.

“Specifically, Sandy is very important to this organization. That doesn't go unnoticed by me. It doesn't go unnoticed by us. Another incredible season. It's a real pleasure to watch him pitch. His leadership in the clubhouse, his demeanor, the example he sets for the rest of the team ... it's unmatched, and I know manager Clayton McCullough appreciates that a great deal, as do I.

“We value him tremendously,” Bendix said during the Marlins' end-of-season news conference in 2026.

Bendix's comments underscored the importance of Alcántara to the franchise, although they did not confirm whether Miami intends to exercise the right-hander's club option.

The decision will ultimately come down to the team's financial plans and its outlook for the coming season. Exercising the $21 million option would keep a proven starter in the rotation, while declining it could allow Alcántara to pursue a multiyear contract on the open market.

For the Marlins, the choice carries implications beyond a single salary figure. Alcántara remains an established presence on the pitching staff, and his value could extend to both his on-field production and his leadership.

As the offseason progresses, his contractual status will be one of the key decisions to watch in Miami. Whether the Marlins retain him for $21 million or allow him to explore free agency, Alcántara appears positioned to remain an important name in the starting-pitcher market heading into 2027.

Major Leagues MLB salary arbitration: $13.3 million projected for four Cuban players in 2027

For more news on Latin baseball, follow our WhatsApp channel.